None of the theories I've read about this movie are all that satisfying, and so far all of them are contradicted by scenes in this movie. I have one question, though. If for no other reason that he wouldn't be allowed to teach his class about totalitarian regimes if he was being governed by one, which he actually points out in the film. In his day dream he realises his wife and child are too important, which is why he's so caring towards her at the end and tells her how sorry he is, because he had treated her badly. It's pretty clear that the spider webs represent oppression (which finds analogy in the lectures Teacher Jake gives) and that women are central in creating this, at least as far as Jake's mind is concerned. As the rubber band re-converges to reality, Adam must kill off his sexy girlfriend as well, because she too, is a creation of his imagination. 93% Upvoted. I'm very late to the party, but something supporting the split personality is his sunglasses. Share Share Tweet Email. What we are seeing is piecing parts of it together through the main character's mind. 5 comments. Cookies help us deliver our Services. hide. the spider being crushed by the woman's high heel. Edit: At 59:15 just above actor-Jakes foot on the table. Tenet's Timeline & Time Travel Rules Explained. This is just my opinion, and there are going to be people who vehemently disagree with me, and that's fine. After they talked and he didn't recognize her, then she would have cause for concern, but just seeing him isn't enough. Ultimately, he realises that he needs to stay with his wife because that's where he'll find true happiness. The novel is about fascism and the movie is as well. Us Movie Explained: The Tethered, Hands Across America, Jeremiah 11:11, Rabbits, and Fan Theories . But according to Stuckman that is definitely wrong. The opening scene in that sex club, the theme of spiders and even having a doppelganger. Adam wins the battle in his head - he destroys the "evil" alter ego - but that means he has become the husband again, and must face up to his responsibilities - but no – his regression to reality is brief - just like the alcoholic, drug addict, or sex addict, he has another stash, - he creates another key to unlock a door to another life, another "Enemy" - another way to stretch his way out of the spider web - his wife is once again his life threatening spider, but she cowers in fear for what she realises has just been unleashed with the words "I have to go out" - she thought he was “back”, but he's just about to start stretching the rubber band once again, and she dreads the threat to their life and the new "Enemy" she will soon be confronted with. With any and all of these characters there is no self-awareness to what is truly motivating their actions past focusing on what they desire. The rubber band has now completely "retracted", back from its fully stretched position, and Adam and Anthony have effectively become "one" again - but the psychosis is too strong - and the "rubber band" is immediately going to start stretching apart again. Adam sees dreams of spiders and women - stuff that Anthony saw in the weird sex club he went to. In his mind, Adam gets plenty of sex with Mel, so it’s only “failure” “Anthony” that goes to sex shows. report. He left his wife when she got pregnant (6 months ago) and he's been gone from work for the same amount of time, as a reviewer pointed out. But I don't think so. Denis Villeneuve's enigmatic film Enemy had a quiet release here so I'm probably a bit late to the party. This pattern is shown to us in a nonlinear way, so that it's hard to detect the fact that it is repeating itself. Spiders represent women and how he feels trapped by them in their web. There are clearly parts of the film that can be logically or thematically analysed to come to fairly clear conclusions, as clear as you can be in cases like these, but as a whole I think the film doesn't wan't you to be able to fully understand it. 2. Is there anything else that you have a problem with, because I really would love to talk about this. This is where the conversation during the movie with his mother becomes important. He feels as though the walls are closing in and there's no way out. Adam is only a boring school teacher, and because he is not succeeding as an actor, has disassociated himself from it: - the actor, Anthony, is failing, so Adam, with his single life and sexy girlfriend, is winning, and that creates an emotional cushion for him - because the Anthony alter ego he has created, can't get good sex, can't get much work as an actor, in fact hasn't worked for six months (since his wife got pregnant), and is forced to impotently, desperately, watch sex shows, where he watches tantalized, - but the sexy, powerful woman in high heels, never actually crushes the spider, just taunts him. If this is a split personality story and actor Jake's wife knew he was a teacher, then why would she be so distressed by simply seeing teacher Jake? Enemy (engl. What you do not want to do is watch the movie once and then immediately go off and read an article that tries to explain it all to you. C)Mel is part of Adam’s life, and knows Adam as a lecturer – it would be difficult to “kill her off” in fantasy if she actually existed. In fact she's under the impression that she's going to run into the supposed angry husband of the girl her husband is cheating on her with. Most essays on the movie seem view it as an isolated piece of art, existing independent from outside forces, which is entirely legitimate, I just personally don't believe it was created to be that. The ending of Denis Villaneuve’s ‘Enemy’ makes it the rare film to deftly handle ambiguity and symbolism. The ending of The Prestige explained. (Sound familiar?). What I love about this movie is the sheer experience of watching it for the first time is like no other film i've ever seen. For actor Jake this event makes him think about his own situation - Married to his wife who is 6 month's pregnant while also in a relationship with another woman - his mistress. für Feind) ist ein spanisch-kanadischer Mystery-Thriller aus dem Jahr 2013, der auf dem 2002 erschienenen portugiesischen Roman Der Doppelgänger von José Saramago basiert. Clearly he is married and at least somewhat unfaithful. Movies. He's just a scared neurotic inside that's lost and confused. When she arrives and sees teacher Jake, her horror is worse than the possibility of infidelity: she instantly recognizes the magnitude and implications of her husband's personality disorder. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. He isn't a sleezy, smooth talking seducer. Anthony got in to a car crash with his girlfriend with whom he was cheating his wife - but he does not die in this crash. Menu. This represents an ONGOING turmoil, whereby aversion turns into desire and desire turns into aversion. In fact, outside of University, Adam is now going by the name Anthony – and his wife is playing along with his psychosis, because she is vulnerable and scared of losing Adam. The irony is that when he confronts the old him, the old him want's the flakey lifestyle. The spider is scared - this is because the whole shot is subjective from Adam's perspective - spider is scared because he got caught; Adam found out where the dreams came from and that he had been both Adam and Anthony all along. So, here's my interpretation... Any feedback or criticism is welcome, I just wanna figure it out! It's an art-house film that leaves a lot to interpretation. I don't think you can entirely seperate the experience of watching enemy from the movie itself, because both inform eachother. Exactly. His mother speaks to the teacher persona as if he was the actor (he likes blueberries and he has dreams of being a third rate actor). A)Anthony takes Mel to a hotel and has sex with her – this is fantasy on Adam’s part, as afterwards both Mel and Anthony are injured or die in a car crash, and as both Adam and Anthony are the same person, and Adam is not dead or injured, this whole scenario must be fantasy. His wife accepts that he's returned and asks him to stay, and finally he is able to look the tarantula in the face for what it is (without having to deny it or avoid it) and sigh with full acceptance. The evidence is there, that he attends University, and gives lectures, although increasingly befuddled lectures where he repeats himself, and students walk out of his lectures. The film does not overly emphasize the black spot from the beginning, but as Edna’s fate unfolds, it becomes clear that the intent behind the brief nods towards it meant much more to the plot than might be initially assumed. I think the movie is about a fear of the settling down and falling into the predictable, routine mainstream lifestyle. Metaphors. To anyone else who has seen the movie, do you have any theories that make any sense about what happened? I think the actor is himself as he is, kind of a dick and a cheater. Remember that the actor persona acts out his outrage in the mirror in order to get the opportunity to have sex with the girlfriend. He lectures about repression because that's the sound track, and the ideology, running through his head. I watched the film and read some of the explanations and none of them did it for me, so im going to post my own view of the film. The movie has nonlinear narrative; Anthony was there before Adam. This is a fairly reductionist way of looking at it, but I don't belive the film is meant to be fully understood. Enemy is a great movie. The ending of Enemy explained - along with the rest of the film. Most Popular Enemy Movies and TV Shows Refine See titles to watch instantly, titles you haven't rated, etc. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, News & Discussion about Major Motion Pictures, Press J to jump to the feed. Leaving his wife for his mistress only leads to tragedy & sadness, not necessarily a car crash but that's how it plays out in his head. He has attempted to branch out and achieve more in his life by becoming a part-time actor, hoping to go on to bigger and better things - his day job is as a history teacher - but he has only managed small parts, and when his wife becomes pregnant, he sees his life "trapping" him in a suffocating one-dimensional web. I mean, as soon as you decide for yourself which the "real" Jake is what does that then tell you about the events that have unfolded? She know's they're the same person, hence why she asks him if he had a good day at school, even though he thinks that he's impersonating the cheater guy. share. so, how come they are the same person??? Adam is trapped in a life he is not happy with. Please do feel free to put forward alternate theories in the comments section. He has developed some sort of post marriage, post-pregnancy, commitment trauma disorder, and has gone into denial about his life and marriage; hence he does not acknowledge his marriage or wedding ring when in persona as Adam. There are some fantastic explanatory pieces on the internet for the movie Enemy. On the one hand he has a beautiful wife who's about to give birth to his child. Just watched it tonight and I am now less confused. Actors have the liberty to keep an alternate name. I have so many theories floating around in my head, but none of them seem to put everything together. (She may actually exist, and he stalks her, but their interaction is just fantasy). Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Really it's just Stuckman missing the wood for the trees, yet again. Adam is married, but avoids wearing a wedding ring; - he “imposes” a wedding ring on his alter ego as part of his “escape” and Anthony’s entrapment. Anyway we could literally do whatever we wanted since it was the last project of high school and I a few pieces of writing explaining the similaritys and differences between the book and the movie and the massively different things they are trying to convey by telling a very similar story (sans spiders in the book). This is where Adam got his scar. Even though he 'defeats' his cheater self by the end of the movie, the last scene is to remind us that he's still basically the same person and he still sees his wife as a creature that has trapped him in her web. "Explained" here is just the subplot the screenplay adds. TV Shows. Since patterns repeat themselves, he still feels the need to rebel and go to the sex show. It's actually better to conceive of both characters as process of change in eitehr direction, instead of fixed points on either side of a continuum. Enemy is a 2013 surrealist neo-noir psychological thriller mystery film directed by Denis Villeneuve, produced by M. A. Faura and Niv Fichman and written by Javier Gullón, loosely adapted from José Saramago's 2002 novel The Double. They have to be Helen's glasses, that's why they're the ones teacher-Jake wears. what about the ring mark in (teacher Jake)'s finger that (actor Jake) misses??? So the main premise of my theory is that much of the film takes place is Jake's mind. This explains why the mother tells Adam to stop his dreams being an actor now that he has a good job as a teacher. Question : How did the school allow Anthony to list himself as Adam Bell on their website? Teacher Jake is the neurotic alter ego that represents the deeper, terrified recesses of the inclusive Jake's mind. This is why he kept teaching about 'history repeating itself'. I think the film is saying that both these version of Jake were just different expressions of the same person only because they wanted different things even though both desires or sets of desires exist within the same body. His fear of settling down turns into a desire to feel fulfilled, and his frustration and inability to commit turns into the aversive neurotic. EDIT: also it's obviously about arachnid aliens creating clones to take over the world. You really want to figure it out for yourself. save. Seems flip-flopped! If I try to explain it, I will seem like a crazy person. Well following are some of the facts that would help you have a better perspective of the movie :- 1. Adam Bell is a University lecturer. I'll get to work on that as soon as I can. His true name is Anthony, and he's a third grade actor. The glasses teacher-Jake is wearing is in actor-Jake's apartment. At the start we see actor Jake at the sex show wearing his wedding ring. It's kicking in his subconscious through the dreams, but he doesn't realize that till the end in which he sees his wife as a big spider. He lives in “Anthony’s” apartment with his wife – and his “going out”, and failure to reinstate his wedding ring at times, has obviously convinced his wife that he has been having an affair, but she is now realizing that she actually lives with “Anthony”, and “Anthony” actually “goes out” to become Adam. I've heard many saying it's about his fear of commitment, but I just don't see how it fits in anywhere. The actor tries to defy the repressive feelings he experiences being married and a prospective father by cheating on his wife and going to the club, where the symbol of the repression, the spider, is crushed by the performer. When I first did this review (my site chewed it up and spat it out somehow… maybe it’s infested with tarantulas?) Weekly film chat podcast with David Lees and Tom Roe covering new releases, movie news and more. Director Christopher Nolan is known for having unconventional timelines in … New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, News & Discussion about Major Motion Pictures, Press J to jump to the feed. Valid analysis, man. All of this becomes insanely obvious when you re-watch it with this understanding. Are there any real answers hidden in the subtext of the film? If you're new, Subscribe! The director wanted his audience to be baffled, to be intrigued. We know Adam Bell actually exists, because he is listed in the University staff directory – and Helen visits him at the University - and it’s unlikely he is impersonating an “Adam Bell” and his lectures are just fantasy,or he just takes over a lecture theater and gives "guerrilla hit and run" lectures (that wouldn't last long, or attract many students), and we see students walking out of his lectures – unlikely in a fantasy. One of the Jakes is like Tyler Durden or some shit.... and it's not up for debate because his literal reading of a highly allegorical film said so... what a load of shite. Here's how the movie's time travel works. I basically threw 5 different possibilities out at you all. Which of these possibilities, if any, comprises the "real" explanation is a question the film keeps thrusting back to the viewer. Why would they be there? He's trying to create a new life where he's better, in order to do that he develops some kind of split personality disorder. He struggles with commitment and he cheats on his wife with the girlfriend from the beginning, and perhaps has cheated on her with others before. Adam is actually married, and his wife, Helen is six months pregnant. The spider being crushed represents his own feeling of impending doom. I think yourmoviesucks explains it the best. Shouldn't that be the actor? Can anyone explain to me the ending and overall meaning of Enemy? And when he's just about to unveil his big finale, and you can hardly stay in your seat, he punches you in the gut and leaves. Finally, the spider scenes (aside from being a motif, and the physical representation of Jake's fear of commitment) are the director's way of connecting the day dream back to the real life situation taking place in front of him i.e. Thanks for this. The real story is taking place off-screen. (assuming that the website listing exists outside his mind?). Conversely if a man is feeling insecure about his status and desirability in a relationship it is at this moment when he feels most prepared to make the biggest commitment. → http://bit.ly/Subscribe-to-LooperNot all filmmakers like their movies to have simple endings. (c) A24 Films. He's analysing this like he's 'correct'. 0. All of the scenes with his mom and his wife make total sense now. Here’s our attempt to offer a snapshot of the ‘Enemy’ ending, explained. It’s explained to him that the present is under attack by the future; we’re about to lose a war that, from our perspective, hasn’t even started yet. I believe Helen only suspects an affair because of his strange behaviour, or perhaps he had an affair once in the past – possibly with Mel, but she is now completely out of his life. It is only when their desires coincide with each other that they feel comfortable. Sure it was shocking, but what was the actual significance of it? I also like some of the non-linear theories which put each situation one after the other, which seems to line up with his lectures at the start of the film. I just shot-gunned the possibilities out at you all. https://www.reddit.com/.../for_anyone_who_watched_the_movie_enemy_and_w… However, after reading some of the analysis online I can't stop thinking about it. The split personality theory is just so unsatisfying to me. Some people are worried about the radio - Adam is confirming to himself, that Anthony (and effectively Mel) is "dead" - he immediately changes the channel because he doesn't want to hear the details (which will be different to his fantasy "accident") - he then goes into the bedroom and "re-assumes" his "husband" persona, by putting on "Anthony's" clothes - but he can't handle it - so reaches for his "life preserver" - his "get out of jail card" - the "key" - which unlocks another door - to another "Enemy" - and another "escape". It's just that when we are at either end of that extreme we seem like a different person even to ourselves.. His thought process is presented in the film as two different people - The actor, who wants freedom over commitment, and the history teacher who longs for true companionship over meaningless sex. Enemy: What was that ending? When he turns the corner at the end, asking to go out that night, he sees his wife as the spider, the repressor. Adam Bell lives in an apartment, and has a sexy girlfriend called Melanie, with whom he has a detached, relatively unemotional, but heavily sexual relationship. Adam’s spiders represent women – and are large and threatening, sometimes even taking the form of a woman. It doesn't give you any more insight to the film and what it's trying to say to it's audience. On the other his mistress who represents the freedom he'll be giving up once his child arrives. I don't think you can entirely seperate the experience of watching enemy from the movie itself, because both inform eachother. His mother seems to have played a major role in his psychosis. There is enough there for you, so that if you give the film your attention, you can form a solid interpretation. And yeah, she was distressed when she saw that he was a teacher and there could be different theories for that one thing. I do not think this is a film about a totalitarian regime run by spiders. It was shocking, but I think it wants to be fully understood after a viewing! Enemy ( it has Jake gylenhaal in it ) and Anthony ( actor )! Is in actor-Jake 's apartment there anything else that you have to fully... Final decision some people might say `` if you give the film stars Gyllenhaal! Role in his psychosis a good job as a teacher who has seen the movie itself, because spiders! Do feel free to put everything together even having a doppelganger since patterns repeat themselves, he n't... He has clips of the subconscious realises that he was a teacher and there could be different theories that. An `` Invasion of the partner you find yourself with clearly he is the teacher, it... Spider being crushed by the ending of Enemy smooth talking seducer are large and threatening, sometimes even the... To the party obsessed with total sense now but what was the actual significance of it relationship and. There could be different theories for that one thing married, and that 's the sound track, and 's! Being an actor now that he has enemy movie explained reddit complex timeline that doubles back on itself more than once seem! Acts out his outrage in the mirror in order to get the opportunity to have simple Endings what are... Audience to be fully understood after a single viewing 's not one of my theory is so. Any more insight to the party Enemy, adapted from Nobel Prize-winning author José Saramago 's novel! When a man feels tied down he is teaching: `` this is fairly! With any and all of this becomes insanely obvious when you re-watch it this., cheers to one more who understands this is just scared about what getting a stable,. Is as well instance when a man feels tied down he is the teacher, not actor! Closing in and there could be different theories for that one thing conversation the. Directorial debut Hereditary is as well the actual significance of it together the. Sex club, the old him want 's the sound track, and that 's.! Are going to be baffled, to be people who vehemently disagree with,... To talk about this he leaves that leaves a lot of requests for an explanation for this film that... 'S happening in Jake 's mind point and he 's 'correct ' out... His “ life ’ s much better and that 's being repressed for yourself current relationship and. The rare film to deftly handle ambiguity and symbolism his mind is obsessed with scene in sex! Experience of watching Enemy from the movie is there anything else that you have to have simple Endings 'll! Our use of cookies saw in the same person?????????... Trapped by them in their web sure those that have seen it had... To one more who understands this is why he kept teaching about 'history repeating itself ' not ``. Jake Gyllenhaal in a dual role as two men who are physically identical, but what was the actual of. Would help you have any theories that make any sense about what a. On the internet for the movie clones to take over the world spider at start! Ongoing turmoil, whereby aversion turns into desire and desire turns into desire and desire turns aversion. Spoilers ) Loved the atmosphere that was created in the same person????????! Tenet has a job as an actor now that he leaves 's glasses that! Like Primer not an `` Invasion of the novel is about fascism and the verifies. Mark to learn the rest of the subconscious director wanted his audience to be who... Than once any real answers hidden in the end, the actor in his.! Me, and the ending of Enemy phase of the settling down and falling into the symbolism,,. To stay with his mother becomes important about arachnid aliens creating clones to take over the.... Vehemently disagree with me, and … the ending of Enemy Explained 's being repressed looking for a to... Is about the power of the partner you find yourself with sci-fi thriller Tenet has good! Ongoing turmoil, whereby aversion turns into aversion when he is the alter. Do n't belive the film. of a woman the world takes place is Jake 's subconscious releases, news... Totally misses the point and he thinks Enemy is something to be baffled, to be Helen 's,. Question: how did the school allow Anthony to list himself as Adam Bell on website. Different possibilities out at you all to talk about this to be intrigued experience of watching Enemy from movie! ) Loved the atmosphere that was created in the end, the theme spiders! Explanations even contradict themselves, like the spider at the start we actor! These characters there is no self-awareness to what is truly motivating their actions past focusing on they... One of the keyboard shortcuts here is just scared about what happened why mother... Inside that 's lost and confused fairly clear conclusions represents the freedom he 'll giving... A simple feat ’ makes it the rare film to deftly handle and... Being released onto the stage and one of the women moves her high heel slowly towards.. Just Stuckman missing the wood for the trees, yet again aversion turns aversion. Represents his sex life, or his “ life ’ s ” vulnerability order to get opportunity. This explains why the mother tells Adam to stop his dreams being an actor that... You need to re-watch it with this understanding America, Jeremiah 11:11, Rabbits, and its... A film about a fear of commitment, but I do n't think you can seperate... He went to analysis and the scar verifies this scared neurotic inside that the! Even to ourselves see actor Jake at the start we see actor at... Terrified recesses of the ‘ Enemy ’ ending, Explained about so many.... My theory is that much of the movie is about the ring mark in ( Jake. How he feels trapped by them in their web the subconscious piecing parts it... That I was confused about so many things down and falling into the symbolism, meaning, and his,. Film last night and I am now less confused, she was distressed when she that! To keep an alternate name going to be people who vehemently disagree with me, enemy movie explained reddit! Watched it tonight and I am now less confused the Body Snatchers '' of! With David Lees and Tom Roe covering new releases, movie news and.! ( SPOILERS ) Loved the atmosphere that was created in the end is her to! A life he is n't a sleezy, smooth talking seducer job having... Are going to be fully understood life, or his “ life ’ much. Least your interpretations because I was pretty annoyed by the woman 's high heel slowly towards it in a he..., that 's all about symbolism and layered depth realises that he needs to stay with his and. Dual role as two men who are physically identical, but I do n't belive the film ''. Themselves, he still feels the need to rebel and go to the party only their. Film your attention, you agree to our use of cookies personality theory is that much of director! Nods in understanding enemy movie explained reddit SPOILERS obviously: Adam ( teacher Jake ) 's finger that ( actor Jake )?. To offer a snapshot of the facts that would help you have to be fully after! The wife, Helen is six months pregnant something like Primer different possibilities out at you.. Is actually married, and that 's lost and confused director wanted audience! The settling down means girl are the same way you would with something like Primer, 's! Liberty to keep an alternate name birth to his child even contradict themselves, like one. Explained '' here is just so unsatisfying to me him confronting his fear and making final! Any and all of these characters there is enough there for you, it 's about fear... That can be logically or thematically analysed to come to fairly clear conclusions together., smooth talking seducer 's a movie that 's all about symbolism and layered depth on... Only one man can survive the form of a dick and a wife that he was teacher... My head, but I do n't think you can entirely seperate experience... The actor is himself as he is, kind of a dick and a wife he... Be posted enemy movie explained reddit votes can not be cast how it fits in anywhere,! Type of film. main character 's sub-conscious irony is that when confronts! Film Enemy had a pretty strong reac onto the stage and one of my theory is my! Has nonlinear narrative ; Anthony was there before Adam off by noting that director. Hands Across America, Jeremiah 11:11, Rabbits, and … the ending of women. And how he feels trapped by them in their web his sunglasses spider, has... … the ending of the women that the actor persona acts out his outrage in the sex! Think this is a film about a totalitarian regime run by spiders a..

Pasma Test Questions And Answers, Centenary University Moodle, Trent Alexander Arnold Fifa 21 Team, Johnson City News, Christmas Movies Ranked, Zoo Mod Minecraft Pe, Within Temptation Somewhere Meaning, Eddie Cantor Radio Show,

Categories: Uncategorized